ST. LOUIS - In a matter of minutes, A.J. Burnett squandered a four-run lead. It was the Pittsburgh Pirates' biggest failure in their latest setback.
"As good as it looked early, it's never easy against this group," said Burnett, who was knocked out in a five-run fifth during the St. Louis Cardinals' 6-5 12-inning victory on Thursday.
"They figured me out early. It's just a matter of putting them away and that's what I didn't do."
ADMIRING HIS WORK — Pittsburgh’s Russell Martin watches as his solo home run leaves the park during the eighth inning against St. Louis Thursday.
-- Associated Press
Matt Carpenter had four hits and scored the winning run on Matt Holliday's single for the Cardinals' second extra-inning triumph over the NL Central leaders in three days.
The Cardinals took two of three in the series to pull within two games of the sagging Pirates, who have dropped five of six. St. Louis won 4-3 in 14 innings in the series opener on Tuesday night.
"They're a good club, we're a good club," said Pirates reliever Tony Watson, who threw three scoreless innings and retired the heart of the order in the 11th. "We get them later in the year, so we'll have to show up big."
Rookie Kevin Siegrist (1-1), St. Louis' seventh pitcher, struck out two in a perfect 12th.
Russell Martin and Clint Barmes homered for Pittsburgh, which blew a 4-0 lead in one inning. Jose Tabata had three straight hits after entering as a pinch hitter.
Carpenter sparked the winning rally with a one-out walk. He went to third on Jon Jay's single before Holliday grounded a single up the middle off Bryan Morris (5-6).
"He did a good job and laid off some pitches that started in the zone and broke away, so my hat's off to him for not swinging," Morris said. "My last pitch, it caught more of the plate than I wanted to and that's about it."
Carpenter, the Cardinals' leadoff man, leads the National League with 48 multihit games and 40 doubles. He entered with league-leading averages of .366 at home and .367 in day games.
Holliday also had an RBI double and has a 12-game hitting streak.
Martin hit a tying leadoff drive off Trevor Rosenthal in the eighth, handing the setup man his second blown save of St. Louis' 4-6 homestand.
The Pirates hit for the cycle against Lance Lynn in a four-run fifth that featured rookie Andrew Lambo's first hit and RBI on a double and Barmes' two-run homer. The Cardinals responded in the bottom half with a two-run single by Daniel Descalso and RBIs in consecutive at-bats from Carpenter, Jon Jay and Holliday off Burnett.
"Everything seemed to be working back towards the middle and up," manager Clint Hurdle said. "There's some things we've tried to identify from the last start and from this start and I think we'll have a conversation to see if any of them are true."
Hurdle didn't seem overly concerned about Burnett, though.
"I know also he's a guy that's experienced everything there is in the game and he will be good and ready to take the ball the next time," he said.
Both managers put a heavy stamp on the game. Hurdle hit for two regulars in the sixth and emptied his bench, and the Cardinals' Mike Matheny used three relievers in the sixth and seventh.
St. Louis activated All-Star catcher Yadier Molina from the 15-day disabled list, and he announced his presence almost immediately. He threw out Starling Marte trying to steal third to end the first.
NOTES: The Pirates begin a three-game homestand Friday against the Diamondbacks. Pittsburgh rookie Gerrit Cole (5-5, 3.95 ERA), who opposes Brandon McCarthy (2-6, 4.73 ERA) in the opener, has lost five of his last six decisions. ... The Cardinals open a three-game series at Chicago, with St. Louis' Jake Westbrook (7-7, 4.11 ERA) opposing minor league callup Jake Arrieta. It will be Westbrook's first appearance since giving up nine runs in 4 2-3 innings of relief on three days' rest after Shelby Miller was knocked out by a liner off his elbow on his second pitch of the game. ... Cardinals reliever Seth Maness, who grounded into a double play and struck out to strand five runners Tuesday night, got his first career hit in the sixth.