Breaking News
Local News

Steubenville Council considers letting voters decide on new fire station

By by LINDA HARRIS 5 min read

STEUBENVILLE -- City Manager Mike Johnson told council Tuesday he's recommending they let voters decide if it makes sense to build a new fire station downtown, though not everyone is happy about it.

In his weekly report, Johnson said he and Fire Chief Joe Ribar had asked Wheeling-based architectural firm M&G to look at the "all-in cost" for a new fire station up to today's health and safety standards, able to accommodate modern-day equipment and also meet the needs of a "diverse" workforce that now includes female firefighters, based on a 15-year repayment schedule.

Johnson said they'll need to have the bottom-line number in the event council decides to proceed with the levy, something council must do by Dec. 15 in order to get it on the May primary election ballot.

Councilman Royal Mayo, however, took umbrage at them for "moving kind of fast."

"I didn't even know this body got to the point that we decided that's what we wanted to do to begin with," he complained. "People talked a lot (at the Nov. 10 council meeting) but it never got to the point where I just said, 'That's what we want to do,' and now we're already sunshining the ordinance saying 'that's what we need'?"

Mayo said if the city "is going to get $10 million from the taxpayers, we need to leverage that into something that's going to generate some revenue and more activities in our city for our citizens."

"Ten million dollars is a lot of money -- if we leverage that, we can possibly get 30, 40 possibly 50 million dollars to build an activity center, something like in the Highlands, and you can have fields and that would generate revenue and bring more people into our city than our fire station."

He also was critical of plans to close the Pleasant Heights station and move its firefighters and equipment into the new station, which he said would lead to slower response times and suggested instead they renovate the existing station.

"We came in and it's 'boom, okay, we're going to do this, we're going to do that and there's been no discussion about it, about the money," Mayo said.

Johnson, though, pointed out both the downtown and Pleasant Heights stations were built in the 1800s "when horses provided the power to move fire equipment. They are inadequate to support today's safety standards, modern equipment, or the needs of our increasingly diverse workforce including female firefighters. The two stations have outlived their useful lives."

He also cited health and safety concerns, pointing out firefighters are exposed to cancer-causing toxins and other occupational hazards. A new station would "have proper ventilation, contamination-control areas and equipment storage designed to reduce firefighters’ exposure to cancer-causing toxins," he said after the meeting. "No longer will a firefighter have to wait in line for over an hour to properly decontaminate. If we expect our firefighters to enter burning buildings, face dangerous situations and put their lives on the line for our community, shouldn’t we provide them with a fire station that protects them, too?”

Johnson said he thinks voters deserve a say in what ultimately happens.

"For too long, when problems arose in the city, the city either put its head in the sand and ignored it or kicked the can down the road for future generations to solve," he said. "As city manager, I refuse to kick the can down the road for our children to solve. Aging fire stations is a health and safety issue that can no longer be ignored. A new fire station should have been built long ago. I am not asking council to raise taxes. Rather, I am asking them to empower the citizens of Steubenville to have a say in the type of fire service that the city will offer its residents for the next 50 years. The issue is of great importance and the citizens deserve to have their voices heard at the ballot box."

Johnson said a 15-year levy was "the smart money move," pointing out it would save taxpayers about $4.8 million in interest compared to a levy with a 27 year term.

"I understand that nobody likes to pay taxes," he said. "For a home value at $100,000, the property tax increase would be about $8 to $10 a month -- that's a small price to pay to upgrade our facilities in order to protect our firefighters and provide them with the necessary tools to continue to deliver life-saving services to the public for years to come."

Fire Chief Joe Ribar, meanwhile, said the Pleasant Heights and downtown stations "were not built for today's fire service" and says comparing the renovations done to the city building -- which included the court room, police locker rooms and restrooms and associated office spaces -- doesn't come close to the magnitude of what's needed in the fire stations.

"(It's) comparing apples to oranges," he said after the meeting. "Firefighters live one-third of their lives in these stations -- no one is living in the court room or in a locker room. Massive overhaul and renovation would have to include adding on to the stations (but) the property we are on is landlocked between roads, building and other properties. This overhaul is far beyond a little bit of paint on some windows."

Starting at /week.