Trending
"The arguments for the bill are essentially emotional arguments. This is a cut at the fundamental rights of parents making a decision over their children in their vehicle. This is a state going where it has no business going (emphasis ours)."
That was state Sen. Mike Azinger, R-Wood, speaking out against a bill that calls for fines for anyone caught smoking or possessing a lit tobacco product in a vehicle when someone age 16 or under is present. The bill passed in the Senate on a 25-8 vote, anyway.
Good. Now let's hope the House of Delegates also does the right thing.
It is an important piece of legislation that will make a dent in one of West Virginia's generational curses. According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Mountain State has a higher rate of adults who smoke than any other state.
Senate Majority Leader Tom Takubo, R-Kanawha, talked about a patient who was never a smoker but still lost half her lung function.
When her father smoked, "she had to climb down to the bottom of the car and put her head underneath the seat," Takubo said.
One wonders if Azinger and a few other lawmakers who think as he does understand the irony of railing against some other personal freedoms -- matters into which they very much believe the state has business going -- yet finding offensive this bill that TRULY protects children.
After all, that is what they say is their bottom line on so many pieces of legislation that seek government control over what should be personal decisions.
In this case, there is no arguing that a child who is forced to spend time -- perhaps lots of time -- in a car with an adult who is smoking is being harmed. The results could even be deadly. That is scientific fact, not emotion.
State senators are to be commended for understanding that, and advancing legislation that could make a difference for some of those kids. Lawmakers in the House considering similar legislation had better not let that good work go up in smoke.